Business rates and 'reasonable repair'
![]() |
The above photograph is indicative and does not relate to the case described below. |
The case of Newbigin (Valuation Officer) v SJ &J Monk (a firm) (2017) concerned the issues of business rates and 'reasonable repair'.
The dispute between a property owner and the local rating office confirmed the principle that if a property is not in a reasonable state of repair, it is to be valued as it is, not as it ‘should be’, or as the Supreme Court put it:
'Does a commercial building which is in the course of redevelopment have to be valued for the purposes of rating as if it were still a useable office?'
The property concerned was an office building which was in the course of being renovated. When the rateable value was being assessed in January 2012, the premises were vacant and a great deal of the flooring, ceilings, lighting and other fittings had been removed.
The owners' agent suggested to the local valuation officer (LVO) that the rateable value should be reduced from £102,000 to £1, because the premises could not be occupied. The LVO refused, citing legislation which required the LVO to assume a property is in 'reasonable repair' for valuation purposes.
The dispute matter was referred to the Valuation Tribunal, which sided with the property owner, holding that the condition of the building precluded the conclusion that it was in reasonable repair.
In considering the arguments, the Court gave weight to the 'reality principle', which establishes that 'the property must be valued as it exists at the relevant date'. Accordingly, the presumption that it was in reasonable repair could not stand.
The decision overturned a decision by the Court of Appeal which had cast doubt on the applicability of the ‘reality principle’. It will come as a considerable relief to property developers who are refurbishing properties.
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles and news
Restoring Great Yarmouth's Winter Gardens
Transforming one of the least sustainable constructions imaginable.
Construction Skills Mission Board launch sector drive
Newly formed government and industry collaboration set strategy for recruiting an additional 100,000 construction workers a year.
New Architects Code comes into effect in September 2025
ARB Architects Code of Conduct and Practice available with ongoing consultation regarding guidance.
Welsh Skills Body (Medr) launches ambitious plan
The new skills body brings together funding and regulation of tertiary education and research for the devolved nation.
Paul Gandy FCIOB announced as next CIOB President
Former Tilbury Douglas CEO takes helm.
UK Infrastructure: A 10 Year Strategy. In brief with reactions
With the National Infrastructure and Service Transformation Authority (NISTA).
Ebenezer Howard: inventor of the garden city. Book review.
The Grenfell Tower fire, eight years on
A time to pause and reflect as Dubai tower block fire reported just before anniversary.
Airtightness Topic Guide BSRIA TG 27/2025
Explaining the basics of airtightness, what it is, why it's important, when it's required and how it's carried out.
Construction contract awards hit lowest point of 2025
Plummeting for second consecutive month, intensifying concerns for housing and infrastructure goals.
Understanding Mental Health in the Built Environment 2025
Examining the state of mental health in construction, shedding light on levels of stress, anxiety and depression.
The benefits of engaging with insulation manufacturers
When considering ground floor constructions.
Lighting Industry endorses Blueprint for Electrification
The Lighting Industry Association fully supports the ECA Blueprint as a timely, urgent call to action.